Skip to content
Forest Advisor Club

Established Politics Triumphs Over Progressive Aspirations in Thai Poll

"At one point, I went to a community event for kids and ended up sitting beside a rival politician. He was grasping a bundle of 100 baht notes to distribute to the children, whereas I had come empty-handed. How could I vie with that?"

Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was part of the "idealistic tide" of youthful hopefuls who surprised Thailand in the 2023 election by capturing more seats for the reformist political group than any other party.

However, in the latest election, he forfeited his seat in his electoral district of Rayong to a challenger from an traditional power clan which has traditionally held positions of power there.

"Back then we were like a storm that overwhelmed and the rival factions could not counter. They believed I was just a unknown candidate. The wave of support for Move Forward in the closing stages of that election really persuaded voters to try change."

Now re-branded the People's Party, their hopes that they would improve on their earlier showing were crushed on the reefs of entrenched patronage networks which have dominated local politics in Thailand during its modern history.

The outcomes are not yet finalized, and a series of election irregularities are being examined, but that won't change the broad result: a dramatic drop of in excess of 20% in the count of seats gained by the People's Party, and a notable increase by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, expanding its number of seats from 71 in 2023 to an projected 193 in the 500-seat parliament now.

'They never address me anymore'

After securing his seat in 2023, Chutiphong immersed himself in his position, touring his electoral area attempting to tackle the challenges faced by his constituents. But he swiftly faced resistance from those working for the long-standing power-brokers. Moreover, he discovered he was required to donate generously, from funds he just did not have.

"An invitation was extended to me to a female empowerment event - a common gathering for the residents to participate in and have fun. But they said if I desired to come, I had to give 25,000 baht. I told them I lacked that money. They were very unhappy about that and said I was cold-hearted. I questioned if there was something else I could do to help out. But they ceased communicating with me from then on."

What he had encountered was a long-standing system of clientelism run by a powerful family.

Rayong is best known as a component of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest manufacturing hub, housing many of the plants which power its export-dependent economy. This has attracted laborers from elsewhere from other regions, and also led to an urban middle class which is more responsive to the progressive policies of the progressive movement.

In 2023, Move Forward swept all five constituencies there.

But a significant portion of Rayong is still rural, the domain of farmers and fruit growers. This is particularly the case in District 4, where Chutipong won his seat. He is a native son, but lived a number of years based in California. The province has for many years been ruled by a influential family dynasty, the Pitutecha family. This is what is known in Thailand as "Big House" – large household – politics, and throughout the country it is the way provincial control has historically been exercised.

Pitutechas manage a large part of the local government.

Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the sitting leading figure, is the elected head of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a immensely powerful position as the PAO manages most government spending in Rayong.

Prior to 2023, Pitutechas had consistently been counted among the MPs voted to parliament, with one serving as the assistant health secretary in Bangkok.

Similar to other "Big House" clans they have no particular loyalty – over time they have stood for several political parties. They are also prominent in the regional commercial sector, and, in contrast to Chutipong, have plenty of money to distribute. It was practically hopeless for the new MP to compete.

The "Baan Yai" depend on widespread webs of local agents - local people who are familiar with their villages, and who organize voters to support their candidate. And although it is officially forbidden, they also provide money before, during, and after elections. They have historically been critical to the victory of regional candidates, and as a new, mostly city-based organisation, the People's Party had lacked them.

"So I changed my approach," says Chutipong. "I announced that I would try to resolve any grievances right away. If your water is not flowing, your electricity is off, your road has craters, I would be there."

"But the residents who sought my help then faced coercion from the local machine. Some were attacked in the village's chat group or through the PA system in the village. They were blamed of allowing me - an intruder they said - into the area."

"On occasions when I attempted to visit factories after receiving some complaints about environmental damage, I faced a negative reaction from the community because they had been receiving payments from these factories."

When it came to the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had adapted after their loss in the last election.

In two key constituencies, they ran junior members of the family, better educated and with a diminished patriarchal aura than the older generation. In District 3 they stood under the Democrat party, historically their chosen political partner, but in District 4, 34-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha ran under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, known for its substantial resources and its skill in recruiting "Big House" to his side.

Chutipong was outmatched.

The Pitutechas regained both seats back from the People's Party, even though the progressives held onto three seats in Rayong.

"They would have welcomed me if I had given them money, but I could not do that permanently considering my financial constraints. I had to decide whether I would be the MP they wanted, or whether I would maintain my values and find out if the villagers would

The writer

Lindsay Ayers

Eva Lindström is a certified forest ecologist with 15 years of experience in sustainable woodland management and biodiversity conservation.

Forest Advisor Club

Type to search articles.